Tree loss is making for sweaty suburbs, and the households that can least afford it are feeling the heat – ABC

By February 21, 2020 April 14th, 2020 Archive

ABC Radio National         By Nick Wiggins and Erica Vowles for Life Matters       2 March 2020

PHOTO: Without trees, many streets on Australia’s urban fringes have no cool spaces along their footpaths. (ABC RN: Nick Wiggins)

RELATED STORY: This Sydney street stays cooler than others during a heatwave — here’s why

RELATED STORY: Too privileged, too bogan: How ‘postcode prejudice’ affects rich and poor

RELATED STORY: How trees can be a ‘cheap and effective’ alternative to air-conditioners

Money might not grow on trees, but it’ll probably buy you a place with more of them.

And more trees in your street can make a big difference, not only keeping things less hot and sticky at home, but also saving you money.

The problem is that in many suburbs trees are disappearing — and the resulting “thermal inequity” affects the people who can least afford it.

Urban and environmental planner Tony Matthews says between 2008 and 2017, Australia’s major metropolitan areas cumulatively lost 2.6 per cent of their vegetation — which adds up to an area larger than Brisbane.

Fewer trees — combined with more hard surfaces like roads, pavements, and rooftops — can create an urban “heat island” effect.

PHOTO: Urban sprawl is resulting in suburbs with fewer trees. (Getty Images: mikulas1)

“Cities become artificially hotter … and that can be variable across the city and much more severely felt in some parts than others,” Dr Matthews, who lectures at Griffith University, tells ABC RN’s Life Matters.

He says the people really feeling the heat are those on the urban fringe, which is often they only place they can afford to live.

PHOTO: Many people rely on air conditioning to keep cool — if they can afford it. (ABC RN: Nick Wiggins)

Many of those people don’t have the option of simply turning up the air conditioning.

“Many of these people are renters, so they can really not afford this. And more than that, they can’t actually do anything about their situation,” Dr Matthews says.

“They’re not in a situation where they could, for example, put solar panels on the roof to offset the cost of air conditioning.”

Listen to the podcast

Trapped in a heat island

Dr Matthews says greenery has a strong correlation with property prices too — living close to a park can inflate value by 5 to 20 per cent.

Western Sydney University’s Abby Mellick Lopes has studied how communities in that area are affected by heat.

Dr Mellick Lopes says for some people, “the only response they could have to an extremely hot day is to remain as still as possible”.

“[That] is obviously not good for health and wellbeing outcomes or for their capacity to connect with other people,” she says.

PHOTO: Western Sydney is one of the areas experts say has been hit hard by the “heat island” effect. (ABC RN: Nick Wiggins)

Dr Mellick Lopes, an expert in design, says rapid development and population growth in Western Sydney has seen trees lost from suburbs, including many lower socio-economic areas.

“You’ve got a large number of people in rental properties which usually have less insulation, and also people are less inclined to feel that they can actually intervene and change those properties to add shade by actually growing trees,” she says.

“So people in those situations tend to be a little trapped because they don’t have those cool spaces where they can actually get from A to B comfortably.

“Often bus stops are not covered as well.”

PHOTO: Hard surfaces like roads and pavements can help create the urban “heat island” effect. (ABC RN: Nick Wiggins)

Landscape architect Libby Gallagher says trees, especially those that can provide direct shade to buildings, can act as “natural air conditioning units for many neighbourhoods”.

It can make a huge difference.

“Some of the research indicates up to three degrees, in some circumstances that can be as high as six to seven degrees centigrade,” she says.

“That actually has a big effect on health, as well as obviously electricity bills and consumption.”

PHOTO: Shade-providing trees, like these in Newtown, can make a big difference to temperatures. (ABC RN: Nick Wiggins)

Who can fix it?

The experts say the responsibility isn’t just on councils and government.

Dr Matthews says in cities, the majority of space is owned by the public.

“Council certainly can affect change on the streets, for example, or in public parks. But when it comes to the individual property owner and the individual building, that then becomes a private property issue,” he says.

VIDEO: These areas north of Brisbane show how tree cover can vary from suburb to suburb (ABC News)

“So it’s trying to appeal to private landowners and building owners to use these technologies, to use green infrastructure, to do more vegetation planting and more tree planting. That’s the real problem.”

Dr Gallagher works with local councils in Melbourne and Sydney, talking with residents about the options for trees in their street and getting them on board before anything’s planted.

She says often people initially have concerns about leaves and mess.

PHOTO: Residents help to plant trees in their Hobsons Bay street as part of Dr Gallagher’s “Cool Streets” program. (Supplied: Gallagher Studio)

“What we find is that when we introduce the wider benefits of trees, when we share with them the research the economic benefits, the impact on their electricity bills, we find that people really transform their perceptions,” she says.

She says tree choice is important too.

“You need to actually think about the right tree, the capacity of that tree to tolerate certain circumstances, even the orientation of the street and the way that the tree shades the street,” she says.

“It’s also designing our streets, our verges properly, so allowing for adequate soil volume and thinking about innovative ways to develop our streetscapes like pavements to prevent cracking.”

PHOTO: Experts say people can feel trapped without cool spaces to escape the heat. (ABC RN: Nick Wiggins)

Dr Mellick Lopes says given trees take a long time to grow, there are things that can be done in the meantime to help people keep cool:

  • Providing shuttle buses to allow people access to cool public spaces like pools or libraries
  • Extending opening hours on these spaces so people can make the most of them in the cooler hours of the evening
  • Looking out for elderly neighbours on days of extreme heat
  • Making the most of DIY solutions to keep homes cooler in the heat

Dr Gallagher says she’s optimistic things can change.

“I can see across all sectors of local government and state government that I’ve been a party to, everybody’s talking about urban heat and the importance of urban tree canopy,” she says.

“I’m really seeing a shift, a significant shift, in perception. And that’s really been driven also by community desire.

“Many people are very keen to see increased canopy in the cities.”


Nearly 200 eucalypt species ‘under threat’ –

Nearly 200 species of Australian eucalypt – about one-quarter of all kinds – should be listed as threatened, researchers say.

Rebecca Gredley         Australian Associated Press   FEBRUARY 20, 2020                  7:09PM

Nearly 200 species of Australian eucalypt should be listed as threatened, researchers say.

This accounts for nearly a quarter of all native eucalypt species.

Scientists from the Threatened Species Recovery Hub assessed all 822 species against the United Nations’ threatened species criteria.

Rod Fensham from the University of Queensland said 193 species met the criteria for a threatened status of vulnerable, endangered or critically endangered.

“This is very concerning as eucalypts are arguably Australia’s most important plant group and provide vital habitat to thousands of other species,” Associate Professor Fensham said.

“The assessment will help Australian conservation managers to better understand those species are at risk, which is important to guiding conservation actions.

Less than one-third of the species flagged for concern are listed as threatened under Australian environmental law, the researchers say.

Land clearing for agriculture and pastoralism, as well as mining and urbanisation are the most common causes for the species being at risk.

The researchers are particularly concerned about the Johnson’s mallee, as there are 600 trees left.

The West Australian region they call home is being targeted for mining.